Growing up, finding a “healthy” fast food option often felt like a mission. Sub sandwiches were a go-to, but today, with a plethora of sandwich chains, choosing the right one is crucial. You need to be prepared with your order, from bread type to vegan options, because the questions come quickly. Picking the wrong place can lead to a disappointing sub experience.
Jersey Mike’s, with its promise of freshly sliced ingredients and customizable options, aims to stand out in the crowded fast-food landscape. But is Jersey Mike’s fast food in the traditional sense? Let’s delve into a taste test to explore their offerings and determine if they truly deliver on quality and flavor.
A Methodical Sub Selection Process
To get a comprehensive understanding of Jersey Mike’s, a selection of their cold subs was tested. The lineup included Jersey Shore’s Favorite, The Number Four, The Turkey and Provolone, The Club Sub, The Original Italian, and The Veggie. All subs were ordered on white bread and prepared “Mike’s Way” with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, spices, red wine vinegar, and olive oil, plus banana peppers and cherry pepper relish for an extra kick.
Jersey Mike’s Subs Ranked: From Worst to Best
Here’s a breakdown of each sub, ranked according to overall taste and satisfaction:
6th Place: The Veggie
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/ar-jerseymikes-Veggie-4×3-51e92e0d31de43488401a7107a3ddb12.jpg)
The vegetarian option (#14 on the menu) features Swiss, provolone, and green bell peppers. In a familiar move for fast-food chains, the absence of meat is “compensated” with extra cheese. Unfortunately, more provolone doesn’t equate to more flavor. The Veggie sub was disappointingly bland, resembling a cheese stick more than a satisfying sandwich. The added banana peppers and cherry pepper relish were crucial for making it palatable. For those still interested, consider adding extra veggies and avocado for a more substantial experience.
5th Place: The Turkey and Provolone
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/ar-jerseymikes-turkeyprovolone-e8d31595dfab4ca0a94db1dd51484756.jpg)
The Turkey and Provolone sub (#7 on the menu) surprisingly didn’t fare much better than The Veggie. While it contained less cheese, the turkey itself lacked any significant flavor, failing to elevate the sandwich. It proved to be a rather uninspired and quickly forgettable experience.
4th Place: Jersey Shore’s Favorite
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/ar-jerseymikes-JerseyShore-a3803f429ae549d393a694a8fed0ffc1.jpg)
Despite its promising name, the Jersey Shore’s Favorite (#2 on the menu) was a letdown. The ham tasted surprisingly similar to the bland turkey, and the cappacuolo (cured pork shoulder), while visually present, was undetectable in terms of flavor. The sub lacked the bold taste one would expect from a sandwich with such a name.
3rd Place: The Number Four
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/ar-jerseymikes-Number4-3da3065c70a04e2d8f7159bcc1fe3219.jpg)
The Number Four (#4 on the menu), boasting provolone, prosciuttini (peppered ham), and cappacuolo, held promise as one of the original nine subs. However, it ultimately underwhelmed. While the combination sounded appealing, the peppery ham and cured meat flavors failed to shine through sufficiently.
2nd Place: The Original Italian
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/ar-jerseymikes-Italian-8d4eb6ef143c4012ba5f79064d0a643a.jpg)
The Original Italian (#13 on the menu) finally offered a distinct flavor profile, largely due to its generous assortment of meats: provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. While the sheer amount of meat made for a tastier sandwich, it still didn’t deliver the intense cured meat punch one might expect. A good option, but potentially not for the faint of heart.
1st Place: The Club Sub
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/ar-jerseymikes-Club-f7e903993d0f44ef829508dec6b52485.jpg)
The clear winner was The Club Sub (#8 on the menu), featuring turkey, ham, provolone, applewood smoked bacon, and mayo. The bacon added the perfect texture and saltiness, while the mayo provided a smooth and creamy complement to the other ingredients. This sub was the most flavorful and satisfying of the bunch, making it a definite re-order.
Jersey Mike’s: Fast Food or a Cut Above?
Despite some underwhelming menu items, Jersey Mike’s still holds its own against other sub sandwich chains. The variety of breads and toppings, the practice of slicing meat and cheese fresh in front of customers, and the consistently good service contribute to a positive experience. While some subs may lack a strong flavor punch, the overall quality and customization options make Jersey Mike’s a worthwhile choice when considering is Jersey Mike’s fast food that’s worth the trip. For a guaranteed win, stick with the Club Sub!
