Choosing the right dog food can feel overwhelming. There are countless options available, each promising optimal health and vitality for your furry friend. But What Are The Top Dog Food Brands that truly deliver on their promises?
Expert Insights
“Navigating the vast landscape of dog food options can be daunting. Consulting with a veterinarian to determine the ideal diet for your dog is invaluable.” — Nell Ostermeier, DVM, CVA, FAAVA, Integrative Veterinarian
A veterinarian can help you navigate these choices by considering your dog’s specific needs, including age, breed, health conditions, and activity level. They can also guide you toward trusted brands that meet the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) standards for complete and balanced nutrition.
To further assist you, we surveyed 407 dog owners about their experiences with various popular dog food brands. They rated the brands based on ease of use, how much their dogs enjoyed the food, ingredient quality, and overall value. Based on their feedback, here’s a look at some of the top-rated dog food brands:
Purina Pro Plan
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/purina-pro-plan-adult-7–shredded-blend-chicken–rice-formula-dry-dog-food-3a29d3a7edf94f0fa1bedcad6f90cae4.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- High-quality ingredients
- Dogs love the taste
- Suitable kibble size for training treats
Red Flags:
- Limited flavor variety
Purina Pro Plan emerged as the most popular brand in our survey, favored by 14% of respondents. It’s considered Purina’s premium line, emphasizing high-quality ingredients, a major consideration for many dog owners. Survey results indicate that most dogs enjoy the taste of Purina Pro Plan, and owners reported their dogs lived to older ages while consuming it.
Purina Pro Plan offers a wide array of formulas, including wet and dry food options for various breed sizes, weight management, and sensitive stomachs. Many appreciate the smaller kibble size, making it ideal for training. However, the flavor options can be limited.
Hill’s Science Diet
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/hills-science-diet-adult-small-bites-chicken–barley-recipe-dry-dog-food-10b10e7b4d8c4c9fa2ac665a8ce7b242.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- High-quality ingredients
- Formulas tailored for specific health conditions
- Different kibble sizes available
Red Flags:
- Wet food containers require a can opener
Hill’s Science Diet received the highest overall score in our survey, excelling in ingredient quality. Many respondents said their veterinarians recommended this brand, especially for dogs with health issues. Hill’s Science Diet offers specialized formulas for weight management, digestive problems, allergies, and prescription diets for urinary and kidney issues.
Hill’s Science Diet provides choices for dogs of different sizes, with Small Bites being easy for smaller breeds. They also offer options for puppies and senior dogs in both wet and dry forms. However, this brand can be expensive.
Purina One
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/purina-one-natural-smartblend-lamb–rice-formula-dry-dog-food-179de51d58dc4516844ea49194aa09fa.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- More affordable Purina option
- Helps maintain healthy weight
- Suitable for dogs with sensitive stomachs
Red Flags:
- Limited flavors
Among surveyed dog owners, 11% feed their pets Purina One, making it a popular choice for dogs with stomach sensitivities. While maintaining high-quality ingredients, it offers a more budget-friendly option compared to Purina Pro Plan.
Purina One provides both wet and dry dog food, including small breed formulas. Survey respondents report that this food helps their dogs maintain a healthy weight, with specific formulas available for weight management, joint health, and skin and coat health. However, Purina One’s flavor options are often limited to chicken or lamb.
FreshPet
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/freshpet-healthy–natural-dog-food-fresh-chicken-roll-9e6544cc547f49ba9dd552b64770a736.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Human-grade ingredients
- Dogs love the taste
- Real chunks of meat
Red Flags:
- Limited store availability
Fresh dog food is gaining popularity, and many surveyed owners feed their dogs Freshpet. This brand uses human-grade ingredients, including meat and vegetables, packaged in refrigerated tubes. Freshpet received high scores for ingredient quality and engagement, with owners reporting their dogs love the taste.
Freshpet offers several food options, including flavors and grain-free choices. However, it’s less widely available than other brands and requires refrigeration.
Blue Buffalo
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/blue-buffalo-life-protection-formula-adult-chicken–brown-rice-recipe-dry-dog-food-f2b111d5b5404273ae05214b692989e6.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- High-quality ingredients
- Promotes coat health
- Smaller kibble size for small breeds
Red Flags:
- Limited formulas for specific health concerns
Blue Buffalo emphasizes high-quality ingredients to keep pups healthy and happy. Respondents reported that this food helped manage digestive issues and improved their pet’s fur. It’s widely available and often more affordable than other premium brands.
Blue Buffalo offers wet and dry food options with various protein choices, beneficial for dogs with allergies or preferences. They also offer dry food with smaller kibble sizes for small dogs. However, Blue Buffalo has limited formulas for specific health concerns.
Iams
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/iams-proactive-health-minichunks-small-kibble-adult-chicken–whole-grain-dry-dog-food-2bf073823dcd44d69d1d9889d53208d3.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Consistent quality over the years
- Promotes skin and coat health
- Reasonable price for the quality
Red Flags:
- Some formulas contain more fillers
Surveyed dog owners appreciate Iams’ consistent high quality over many years, with good ingredients in its formulas. It helps with coat health, and the price is reasonable for the quality.
Iams offers a moderate selection of dry dog food, but its wet food options are limited. There are formulas for different life stages and breed sizes, but fewer options for health problems, although Iams Proactive Health Healthy Weight can assist with weight management.
Royal Canin
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/royal-canin-size-health-nutrition-small-adult-formula-dog-dry-food-08228010686f4a698a1dc6029c1d6478.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Breed-specific formulas
- Digestible proteins
- Kibble tailored to different snout sizes
Red Flags:
- Kibble size consistency can vary
Royal Canin offers breed-specific formulas designed for breeds prone to certain health problems. For example, the Royal Canin Breed Health Nutrition French Bulldog Dry Dog Food features unique kibble shapes for short snouts, reducing gas and stool odor with digestible proteins.
Survey respondents give Royal Canin high marks for ingredient quality, citing its positive impact on dog health. A common complaint is kibble size inconsistencies between bags, and it can be more expensive than other brands.
Kirkland Signature
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/kirkland-signature-adult-formula-lamb-rice-and-vegetable-dog-food-a98e335b73c24218b798024c03209a26.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Highest rated for value satisfaction
- Comes in large bags
- Good ingredient quality for the price
Red Flags:
- Primarily sold at Costco
Kirkland dog food, Costco’s in-house brand, is recognized for its quality and affordability. The food comes in 40-pound bags, containing ingredients like sweet potato, lentils, and salmon.
There are formulas for different life stages, but Kirkland mainly offers dry kibble with only two basic wet food options.
Purina Beneful
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/purina-beneful-originals-with-real-beef-adult-dry-dog-food-c3426b77f09942c681132692c6d12b99.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Mix of kibble shapes and textures
- Reasonably priced
- Easy to find in stores
Red Flags:
- Owners desire more meaty pieces
Beneful, another brand made by Purina, can be a good choice for picky dogs, due to its mix of kibble shapes and textures. Survey respondents say this keeps their dogs interested and slows down eating. The brand is also affordable and widely accessible.
Beneful offers both wet and dry food with several flavors, including small-breed-specific products like the Beneful IncrediBites Small Dog.
Fromm
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/fromm-large-breed-adult-gold-premium-dry-dog-food—dry-adult-dog-food-for-large-breeds-2e963f7c1ade471f8ab8d026c6ce356c.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Clean, high-quality ingredients
- Made in the USA
- Family-run brand
Red Flags:
- Can be hard to find
Fromm is known for its clean, high-quality formulas with minimal fillers, and owners appreciate that Fromm has been family-owned for generations and manufactures its food domestically. The brand can be pricier and harder to find.
Pedigree
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/pedigree-complete-nutrition-ecaaefce0d5b4e2a85b0108f657f403e.jpg)
Star Qualities:
- Inexpensive dry food
- Dogs like the taste
Red Flags:
- Lower ingredient quality
Pedigree offers budget-friendly food that dogs enjoy, according to our survey. It scores high in value, with larger quantities available for less. The brand is widely available.
Pedigree sells both wet and dry food, including formulas for different breed sizes and weight management. However, Pedigree’s ingredients are not the highest quality, with many foods listing corn as the first ingredient.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(1799×0:1801×2)/peo-dog-harnesses-test-kurgo-tru-fit-quick-release-seatbealt-tether-smart-front-back-attachment-pr-sara-luckey-03-81a2c946c4ac434081096a9d6af96f0f.jpg)
Key Considerations When Choosing Dog Food
When selecting top dog food brands, there are several factors to keep in mind.
Nutritional Adequacy
Ensure the food provides complete nutrition for your pet. “It’s important to ensure that you are feeding a complete and balanced diet — this information should be readily available on the label,” says Dr. Ostermeier.
Look for the Nutritional Adequacy Statement, indicating that the food meets AAFCO standards.
Food Type
There are several types of dog food:
- Dry Food: Affordable and easy to store, but can be highly processed.
- Wet Food: More flavorful for picky eaters and hydrating.
- Fresh Foods: Lightly cooked and beneficial, but harder to store.
- Raw and Homemade Diets: Consult with your veterinarian to ensure they are nutritionally adequate.
Budget
Dog food prices vary significantly. Consider how much food your dog needs daily and the package sizes available.
Conclusion
Choosing the right dog food is a crucial decision for your pet’s health and well-being. By considering factors such as ingredient quality, nutritional adequacy, food type, and your budget, you can confidently select the top dog food brand that best suits your furry friend’s needs. Always consult with your veterinarian for personalized recommendations and to address any specific health concerns.
