Ash in cat food is a term that often raises questions among cat owners. It refers to the inorganic mineral residue that remains after the organic components of the food are completely burned away. This residue represents the total mineral content, which can include various elements like calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, potassium, sodium, silicon, sulfur, and trace minerals. Understanding what ash is and its role in cat food is crucial for making informed decisions about your feline’s diet.
What Exactly is Ash Content in Cat Food?
The ash content is determined by heating a sample of cat food to a very high temperature, typically between 550 and 600 degrees Celsius. This process incinerates all the organic material, leaving behind the inorganic minerals. The remaining residue is then weighed, and its proportion relative to the original food sample is reported as the ash content on the product’s guaranteed analysis.
Debunking the Myth: Ash and Urinary Crystals
In the past, there was a misconception linking ash content in cat food to the development of urinary crystals and Feline Lower Urinary Tract Disease (FLUTD). This belief stemmed from observations in the 1970s and 1980s when veterinarians were investigating the causes of FLUTD, previously known as Feline Urologic Syndrome (FUS).
However, further research has revealed that ash itself is not a primary cause of urinary issues in cats. The main culprit was often the formulation of commercial pet foods, which tended to create a more alkaline urine environment (higher pH). This alkaline environment can promote the formation of struvite crystals, composed of magnesium ammonium phosphate.
The Role of Urine pH and Magnesium
The pH level of a cat’s urine plays a significant role in the formation of urinary crystals. Diets high in vegetable and grain content, common in dry kibble, can lead to alkaline urine. In contrast, a high-meat diet, similar to what cats would naturally consume, helps maintain a more acidic urine pH, which is beneficial for urinary health.
While magnesium was also once implicated in FLUTD, it’s now considered a less significant factor compared to urine pH. Studies have demonstrated that supplementing a cat’s diet with magnesium chloride doesn’t necessarily lead to crystal formation, as long as an acidic urine pH is maintained. Conversely, struvite crystals can develop even with low magnesium levels if the urine pH is high (7.5 or greater).
Understanding Magnesium in Cat Food
Magnesium is an essential mineral for cats, contributing to various bodily functions, including energy production, muscle function, heart health, and the maintenance of strong bones and teeth. Instead of focusing solely on magnesium content, it’s more important to consider the ratio of calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium in the diet. An appropriate ratio is approximately Ca-1.3:P-1:Mg-.06.
Pet food manufacturers initially developed low-ash and low-magnesium foods in response to the incorrect belief that these components were the cause of struvite crystals. When it became clear that urine pH was the key factor, manufacturers began adding ammonium chloride to cat foods to acidify the urine.
However, this practice can have unintended consequences. Long-term use of ammonium chloride can lead to chronic acidosis, which can cause calcium to be drawn from the cat’s bones. This combination of chemically induced acidosis, calcium loss, and reduced magnesium levels can contribute to the formation of oxalate stones, which have become an increasingly common concern.
Choosing the Right Diet for Your Cat
The best diet for your cat is one that promotes a healthy urine pH and overall well-being. A high-protein diet can help maintain a normal urine pH, reducing the risk of crystal formation. Wet cat food, with its higher moisture content, can also be beneficial compared to dry kibble, as it helps with hydration and can contribute to a healthier urinary tract. Some cat owners also consider raw food diets, which can help maintain normal urine pH and support hydration levels.
Cats naturally have a low thirst drive, and in the wild, they obtain most of their moisture from their prey. A cat eating dry kibble needs to consume a significant amount of water (approximately 8 ounces per day) to maintain adequate hydration.
Conclusion
While the term “ash” in cat food may sound alarming, it simply refers to the mineral content essential for your cat’s health. The focus should be on maintaining a balanced diet that supports a healthy urine pH and provides adequate hydration, rather than solely avoiding ash or magnesium. Consulting with a veterinarian is always recommended to determine the best diet for your cat’s individual needs and health status.
Further Reading:
